Accolades & Quackolades


"There are ~20 published reviews of my book, but this one must be THE BEST! THANK YOU."
Edzard Ernst

"Best blog of the day IMHO."
Simon Singh

"This blogpost is simply brilliant."
Mark Burnley

"You are a rude argumentative bully. You are a typical "skeptic" - not sceptical at all."
Andrew, anti-vaxer

"Your piece about House of Commons Science and Technology sub-Committee’s ‘evidence check’ on homeopathy was one of the best I’ve seen. Strength to your elbow."
Tony

"...an individual calling themselves ‘scepticat’ or ‘sceptikat’- a highly volatile dictatorial site run by a wannabe megalomaniac. A truly disturbed person with a anger management issue venting via their little site to their own personal herd of sycophants."
Centella, one of Dr Andrew Jones personal herd of sycophants.

"Excellent report, which I can vouch for completely."
Jack of Kent

"The ludicrous nature of the complaint, and some of the responses by Dr Ranj and the BBC, has already been expertly documented on the Skepticat UK blog".
Dean Burnett

"Choke on your own vomit and die in agony..."
r wesley edwards, aka @CommonCormorant, author

"A very good rebuttal…"
Anna Watson, anti-vaxer Arnica UK

"A staggering amount of pathological disbelief allied with a staggering amount of arrogance."
Antony J Palmer, homeopath

"I just love this blog, and this post is a fine example of it’s content – ‘Inside the spine wizard’s den’ – Skepticat. Why do some of us feel that we are above challenging argument and peer review? I just wish that I could write as well as some of these bloggers!"
Jonathan Hearsey, osteopath

"Skepticat is a particularly venomousness (sic) skeptic, a humanist who lives by the "golden rule", she refused to let me follow her on twitter because I am "bonkers" which may endear her to many in the chiropractic profession..."
Richard Lanigan, chiropractor


Facebook image helpfully captioned by Sandra A Hermann-Courtney (@brownbagpantry)


"Die Die die die!"
r wesley edwards, aka @CommonCormorant, author

"Loved that article. It really shows what chiropractors are really all about. What I call the "chiro show" Exposing people to totally unnecessary X-rays should be criminal. Thank you!"
mt

"I think skepticat is plain mad at not having children of her own. Hatred projected out to the world. It's sad to see someone with so much self hatred, destroying themself internally without even realising it."
Bebo, chiropractor (Note: In fact I'm the proud mother of two brilliant children, whom I mention frequently. Glad of the excuse to do so again.)

"Hooray for Reason! Just want to thank you for writing this. Even though the arguments presented are tired, and played out, they still must be refuted."
Elijah

"I understand that you have been traumatised by your experience and that this is your way of coming to terms with the emotional scars."
Stefaan Vossen, chiropractor

"All you really seem interested in is banging your repetitive drum and preaching to the converted."
Rick, osteopath

"All the entries I’ve read are excellent. I’ll be coming back to read more. Love the cat logo as well."
Derrik

"Research in Homeopathy Conference - Skepticat's hilarious account. She went to it."
David Colquhoun

"Her site is Skepticat UK... she wouldn’t know a punchline if it raped her. Or maybe she’d thank it."
Scott Cappurro, comedian

"I rather love the lunacy of the anti-Homeopathists, such as yourself."
James Pannozzi, acupuncturist & would-be homeopath

"Good blog from a skeptic which examines the "science" of Homeopathy in a very detailed way. Skeptics will love this. Proponents of homeopathy? Not so much."
SidDithers

"I really shouldn’t waste my valuable time with someone who obviously has at the very least a borderline personality disorder."
Erika Alisuag, homeopathist

"I’m finding it difficult to come up with some suitable words to say how good and interesting your stuff is. So, in the absence of suitable hyperbole can I say what a very well written and presented blog you have here. Really well thought out and researched. And passionate about it too! Complimenti!"
pv

"You’re whole life is worthless because you lack reason."
Antony J Palmer, homeopath

"Great stuff Skepticat."
Lifelinking

"When you have learnt some big words and also studied your history books you’ll find that the world was once thought to be flat…by people just like you."
Sarah Hamilton, homeopath

"Thanks for keeping the banner of reason flying high."
John Willis Lloyd

"This is just a general comment. I love this well-written an unfussy little blog (I don’t mean little in a derogatory way, but in the sense it’s not bombastic, self-important and posturing). Excellent material and a worthwhile focus, keep up the good work."
xenophon19

"Her website is a temple to diatribe – I have no sympathy for the homeopaths, etc, with whom she battles, but she clearly gets off on confrontation."
JF Derry

"Skepticat is strictly logical and attacks in unparliamentary words what she deems to be “quackery” – or suggestions that she sounds a little strident."
Andy Reporter

"LOVE the badass attitude! Seriously...KEEP IT UP!"
HelpIzOnTWay

"You were a playful little diversion for a. moment, but I do have better things to do with my time than waste more than half an hour of it stooping down to play your ego supporting self delusional mind games……"
Susan Elizabeth, homeopathist

"An excellent read, thanks for taking thr time to compose it."
Alan C

"You need to do a course in anger management."
katenut, nutritionist

"FWIW I think you manage your anger rather well...mostly by focusing it into a thin, narrow beam of incisive rage which you then use to inscribe words on screen. ;)"
Despard

"Excellent description of the events."
Simon Perry

"You seem to be of probably well-meaning, but bigoted and fundamentalist disposition, just parroting slogans from others without any really knowledge or insight yourself."
Neil Menzies

"Superb, as usual"
phayes

"You seem only interested in ranting against an enemy which you are apparently still struggling to come to terms with “fifteen years” later."
Rick, osteopah

"Bravo, great post!"
RBO

"One day if you are not very careful you will be left behind in the dark ages. I’m sure this will not be printed..but hope it is read by you poor little scaredy cats."
Sarah Hamilton, homeopath

"Brilliant piece!"
crabsallover

"While you babble on like a total airhead about Myhill, you ignore the real doctors who are a danger in the UK".
struck-off doctor, Rita Pal, 'NHS whistle-blower'

"I sincerely hope I never get to your stage of wilful ignorance. You know absolutely diddly squat about the subject but you think your opinion is the only opinion."
Antony J Palmer, homeopath

"Keep up the spin, you manky old chicken's foot."
JB, chiropractor

"I am forced to conclude you are blogging on behalf of a specific entity that does wish to remain anonymous."
Antony J Palmer, homeopath

"The person writing all this negative press on homeopathy must be getting a big fat check from one of the pharmaceutical companies who would dearly love to push homeopathy off the map."
Erika Alisuag

"Such reporting lands you clearly in the realm of fundamentalist extremism–much noise, no substance, and money from those who have something to sell. It is so unfortunate that your listening skills are in need of repair."
Tanya Marquette, homeopath

"She seems to revel in presenting the many insults that she has attracted as a column of “Quackolades” on her site, as if war wounds on display,"
JF Derry, self-publicist

"Oh shut up SK. You write hot air and spew rubbish as usual."
Rita Pal again.

How the spine wizards tried to trap me

I was unpleasantly surprised to find a bunch of spine wizards touting for business in front of my local Sainsbury’s superstore recently. At a time when the chiropractic branch of the…um…’healing arts’ in the UK is fighting tooth and nail to hang on to any vestige of credibility during the current onslaught of challenges by quackbusters, it seemed a strange way for people claiming to represent a serious healthcare discipline to behave. The only other hucksters I’ve seen hanging round Sainsbury’s are car washers.

spinaltrapBut, hey, they’ve got to make a living somehow and I’ve got to find material for this blog so, naturally, I took advantage of their offer for a free spinal check. It so happened that I was suffering from a bit of an ache across the top of my shoulders and I knew the reason was the terrible posture I’d adopted over the past few months after switching to using a laptop on the couch instead of sitting at a desk.

I asked the chiropractor, Dr Canard, (not her real name and certainly not her real qualification) what she was looking for, as she prodded my neck with cold fingers. I was listening for the buzz word, ‘subluxations’, which is what the original idea of chiropractic was based on, subluxations being out-of-place bones in the spine, which were believed by the founding father of chiropractic, D.D. Palmer, to be the cause of most cases of disease. As I said in a previous post,

Funnily enough, these chiropractic subluxations, didn’t show up in x-rays, an inconvenience chiropractors addressed by changing the definition of subluxation from the partial dislocation that Palmer imagined to “a lesion or dysfunction in a joint or motion segment in which alignment, movement integrity and/or physiological function are altered, although contact between joint surfaces remains intact. It is essentially a functional entity, which may influence biomechanical and neural integrity”. (Source: The World Health Organisation quoted by Wiki.)

But Dr Canard managed to avoid using the word, preferring instead to talk of misaligned vertebrae, which sounds like pretty much the same thing to me.

“I can feel something here,” she said.  To her credit, she had found exactly the place on my neck where I had the most pain and she mentioned my poor sitting posture as a possible contributory factor. I was impressed. But not for long. She could feel several more “blockages” as she groped up and down my spine through my coat and two more layers of clothing, even though I had no pain whatsoever below my shoulders. I asked what a blockage was and I was rewarded with a demonstration involving a model of a spine, with moveable vertebrae. Along the spinal colum were small holes, each with bit of rubber, representing the nerves, threaded through it. A misaligned vertebra can put pressure on nerves protruding from the spinal column, I was told. “These ones here,” she said, pointing to vertebrae in the middle of the spine, “cause digestive problems when they become misaligned.”

“How?” I asked

“Well,” she said hesitantly, “these nerves here are connected to the digestive system…” Her explanation petered out before it really got going so I’m still none the wiser. She seemed taken aback by my barrage of questions and I didn’t get a satisfactory explanation about anything. What was clear from our exchange was that this was a fundamentalist chiropractor who subscribed to the unproven, implausible and discredited theory that conditions that have nothing whatsoever to do with the spine can, in fact, be treated by “adjusting specific vertebrae that need to be corrected,” even though there isn’t a jot of scientific evidence to support this idea.

On the subject of what treatment I needed, she was more forthcoming: if I made an appointment there and then for a full examination at their clinic, I could have it for the bargain price of £30 instead of the usual £95. I didn’t enquire about the price of the “several sessions” of treatment she thought I might need but asked instead whether simply making a concerted effort to improve my posture might help. “I’d still recommend treatment because the longer you leave a problem untreated, the greater the danger of degenerative disease,” came the predictable reply.

Having stood and watched for a while as other people got their spines checked, I noticed that none of these people seemed to be asking questions as their backs were prodded and poked and, more often than not, they meekly signed on the dotted line for their cut-price appointment. Anyone presenting with any kind of ache or pain in any part of the body was given the hard sell, thereby confirming my previously held view that these people were basically horseshit pedlars whose product, if it could be bottled, wouldn’t look out of place on the shelves of that well-known retail outlet for all sorts of woo, Boots the chemist.

The next day I bought a £15 laptop table from IKEA and my shoulders haven’t ached since.

Finally, for those who haven’t seen this, enjoy!

6 Responses to How the spine wizards tried to trap me

  • “I was unpleasantly surprised to find a bunch of spine wizards touting for business in front of my local Sainsbury’s superstore recently….The only other hucksters I’ve seen hanging round Sainsbury’s are car washers.”

    I think you’re being very unfair to them…to the car washers, that is, who are at least doing an honest day’s work.

  • So you don’t exactly say what she said that was wrong. What facts exactly are you using to disprove her? Seems like you just like to call them names–which doesn’t disqualify anyone.

  • Oh for pity’s sake, Wrong, take your blinkers off and have another read.

    In a nutshell: She was asked simple questions about the theory she was promoting that she couldn’t answer. She claimed that conditions that have nothing to do with the spine can be treated by adjusting spinal verterbrae even though there is no scientific support for this idea. She tried to lure me into an examination I didn’t need by scaremongering about degenerative disease.

    What fact am I using to disprove her? The fact that the ache in my shoulder cleared up as soon as I took a very simple step to improve my posture!

    Got it now?

  • A friend of me recently had spine surgery by (I guess professional people since they studied for more than 10 years at Uni).

    Since then his left leg feels numb, he even doesn’t feel his foot at all, and the wounds don’t heal anymore.

    Do you mean this kind of spine wizards?
    I didn’t read the comment, only the title, since I don’t have much time to waste.

  • LFMAO! You obviously have enough time to leave silly comments. Come on, hiliarony, you’re fooling nobody. You read my post, couldn’t think of a good argument against any of it but still felt wound up and wanted to say something so you post some irrelevant anecdote about something else entirely. Hope you feel better for it. 😉

  • greance stuff but as a qualified physio with over 20 years experience i am not at all surprised, i have had to endure over the years many in services where colleagues have been on expensive courses by so called experts and come back and tried to promote unfounded crap to disinterested professionals who use the techniques for a few months and then move onto something else- if your car was treated in such a slipshod manner you would see them on rip off britain! had the mis fortune to endure a car crash recently and the insurance company sent me to an expert gp he told me he could feel scar tissue in my neck! when i told him my profession he got quite upset presumably as he thought he was maybe wasting his expensive time on me!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Gravityscan Badge

Categories
Archives